IÂ’m spoiled already. Seven weeks into this column, and I yawn when I see a DVD with Âonly one audio commentary. It wasn’Ât even seven weeks when I succumbed to the ÂCriticÂs Disease, judging each new entertainment against the one I had seen the day, week, month, or year before.
For the most part, the illness symptoms aren’Ât as egregious for DVDs as they are for films, since itÂ’s likely most people see more DVDs than go to the movies, and therefore have touches of the malady themselves. Besides, as I pointed out before, expectations are far lower for films seen on TV than they are in the cinemas.
Even so, some worthy discs (or double discs) can slip through the cracks while IÂ’m la-di-dahing. Such is the case for Fantastic Four Extended Edition I first mentioned a column or two back. DonÂ’t get me wrong: the actual film, despite the twenty minutes of reinstated footage, still isnÂ’t as good as it could or should have been. But in the weeks since reviewing it, my memory keeps going back to the special features.
So now I feel I could have been a bit more adamant about the editionÂs charms, especially with this siteÂs readers. Maybe I should have mentioned that the extras come in two categories: the film, and the comic book. And it is in this latter category where the glory of this version truly lies. There are new, lovingly created docs Âeach more than an hour long  on the history of the comic from the 1960Âs until today, and on co-creator/artist supreme Jack Kirby.
Each features the cream of the comic worldÂs crop (Stan Lee, Jim Lee, George Perez, Marv Wolfman, Walt Simonson, Len Wein, Alex Ross, and many others) waxing enthusiastically about their writing and artistic contribution to the series (save for John Byrne, whose absence is accusatory, though his input is lauded) as well as the man who inspired them. Remember, grasshoppers, that the climatic locale for the first season of Heroes was called Kirby Plaza for a reason. The docs do a nifty, pleasing job of balancing art images with talking heads, and the overall effect is a warm and fuzzy feeling for a film that wasnÂt that rousing to begin with.
The first Fantastic Four film should be so lucky as to be remembered with the same fondness as itÂs Âfantastic predecessor, Fantastic Voyage. In addition to sharing an adjective (or is that an adverb?), 20th Century Fox has released special editions of their respective DVDs at the same time. But Voyage, incongruously, is part of FoxÂ’s ÂCinema Classics Collection. (more…)