Author: Robert Greenberger

Watching the Watchmen
Dave Gibbons
Titan Books, $39.95In January 1985, DC Comics sent me to England to begin meeting with the talent working across the pond, reminding them of our needs and working environment.  Dick Giordano and Joe Orlando had been out a few years prior so this was like a booster shot, a tangible sign we loved them and wanted to keep working with them. Titan Books’ Nick Landau helped me organize two group dinners with the rising stars working for [[[2000 AD]]] and [[[Warrior]]] and it was first introduction to them all.

Apart from that, though, was an afternoon session with Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons.  Alan’s work with [[[Swamp Thing]]] had already proven captivating and I was an instant fan.  Dave’s work was newer to me but I immediately liked his style.  Interestingly, Dave’s first issue as penciller of [[[Green Lantern]]] and Alan’s first issue as writer of [[[Saga of the Swamp Thing]]] were both cover dated January 1984, just months before I joined DC in the actual January 1984 so I had a year to know their work before meeting.

Both were brimming with enthusiasm for [[[The Watchmen]]], the project they were just getting started on and I had heard about in the hallways. We spent the afternoon sipping tea at the Tower Hotel as Dave pulled out pages of drawings and sketches while Alan talked through the themes of the series. If Dave’s chronology in [[[Watching the Watchmen]]] is correct, our meeting was weeks before the first script was delivered. By then, though, they already had the tag line “Who Watches the Watchmen?” and the bloody smiley face design.

This was going to be a sophisticated story, the like of which was just beginning to find a place amidst the more traditional good versus evil stories that filled the racks. That translated to cover design and even the gents’ notions of how to market the book.  Dave showed off designs for cocktail napkins and coasters that they’d imagine DC printing up to entice college kids and adults to be made aware there was something new to read.

Sadly, those marketing designs seem to have vanished but most of Dave’s other designs, sketches, notes, annotated scripts and paraphernalia was retained.  The result is this handsomely designed book that enhances your enjoyment of the graphic novel and keeps you enticed until the feature film finally arrives in March.

Gibbons writes honestly about the creative process, nicely explaining how things were done back then compared with today.  His recollections are vivid and explain much of what went into the process of conceiving something entirely new rather than rehashing the Charlton heroes (truth be told: I was the one to commission Dave to draw the characters for the aborted [[[Comics Cavalcade Weekly]]] for that very reason). Some of his personal thoughts about favorite characters, scenes, and moments would have been icing on a rich, delicious cake.

Chip Kidd’s design lets the work breathe and makes certain you can see the detail in the thumbnails or color guides.  He takes Dave’s traditional comic book approach to storytelling and enhances it with size and scope. My only quibble is that he lets thumbnails run in the gutters and spoils some of the clarity.  Also, it’d be nice to have seen more of Alan’s scripts and Dave’s notes to better understand the process.

Overall, the big is a huge visual treat and one of the few in-depth looks into the creative process behind any single title.  It’s really the first Making Of book for a comic book that I can recall and there’s no better series than The Watchmen to get the in-depth examination.

Every year, the Library of Congress’ National Film Registry names 25 films for historic preservation.  This year’s list was announced yesterday and we applaud the inclusion of several genre offerings including The Invisible Man and the first Terminator film.  The Perils of Pauline, the first movie serial, makes the list and is seminal for the way it influenced moviemakers and storytellers, notably comic book writers, ever since.

Here’s a look at this year’s list:

The Asphalt Jungle (1950)
John Huston’s brilliant crime drama contains the recipe for a meticulously planned robbery, but the cast of criminal characters features one too many bad apples. Sam Jaffe, as the twisted mastermind, uses cash from corrupt attorney Emmerich (Louis Calhern) to assemble a group of skilled thugs to pull off a jewel heist. All goes as planned — until an alert night watchman and a corrupt cop enter the picture. Marilyn Monroe has a memorable bit part as Emmerich’s "niece."

Deliverance (1972)
Four Atlanta professionals (Burt Reynolds, Ned Beatty, Ronnie Cox and Jon Voight) head for a weekend canoe trip — and instead meet up with two of the more memorable villains in film history (Billy McKinney and Herbert Coward) in this gripping Appalachian "Heart of Darkness." With dazzling visual flair, director John Boorman and cinematographer Vilmos Zsigmond infuse James Dickey’s novel with scenes of genuine terror and frantic struggles for survival battling river rapids — and in the process create a work rich with fascinating ambiguities about "civilized" values, urban-versus-backwoods culture, nature, and man’s supposed taming of the environment.

(more…)

Action adventure movies work best when you have someone to root for or something to think about. Ideally, the movie offers both otherwise the action is mindless and the time in the theater wasted.  [[[Eagle Eye]]] makes you think about the price of privacy as a government entity known as Aria uses every digital piece of data available to manipulate people into help it execute a program design to sever the Executive Branch of the government from the waking world.

The film focuses on the prime players, a slacker named Jerry Shaw (Shia LaBeouf) and a thirtysomething paralegal Rachel Holloman (Michelle Monaghan) who are directed by a feminine voice to comply with orders or things would get bad for them.  In Jerry’s case, he’s framed by Aria as a potential terrorist in the wake of his Air Force lieutenant twin’s death.  For Rachel, her eight year old son’s life is threatened as the boy travels with the school band to Washington to perform at the State of the Union address.

The computer gives them no choice and sees to it that they can follow orders by keeping the police and federal investigators, headed by Billy Bob Thornton and Rosario Dawson, at bay by manipulating street lights, automated construction equipment, and much more.  All along, others have been manipulated to help construct and deliver the means by which Aria intends to rid America of its “corrupt” leaders and begin anew.

Jerry and Rachel find themselves thrown together and learn to trust one another as their three day odyssey takes them from Chicago east towards Washington.  Given their age and background differences, the two avoid the film cliché of falling in love and pausing form saving the world to having sex.  Instead they rush breathlessly towards their destiny.

While the film has lofty goals it fails to work on several levels.  Watching the film with a member of the federal government meant a running commentary of security flaws such as Thornton and Dawson discussing sensitive matters over an unsecure channel.  Also, we’ve seen the computer taking the world to the brink of destruction once a generation starting with the brilliant [[[Colossus the Forbin Project]]] and more recently in John Badham’s [[[War Games]]]. Heck, Aria is merely a cousin to HAL and needs to be deactivated for many of the same reasons. The cross country chase, playing beat the clock, has also been done to death especially when you add in the pursuit in the form of Thornton’s dogged fed. The nice thing about the latter is that at least screenwriters Dan McDermott, John Glenn, Travis Wright, and Hillary Seitz rounded out Thornton’s character without making him the usual one- note player.

That Aria can control all these devices is interesting and when she projects Jerry and Rachel’s lives on television screens to demonstrate how much is recorded and available for research (or blackmail) purposes, the message comes through loud and clear that we have all given up our privacy bit by bit. That’s plenty of good for thought and the featurette “Is my Cell Phone Spying on Me?” is the most compelling piece on the two-disc collector’s set, now on sale.

The variations on a theme are all appreciated but still don’t add up to something that’s greater than the sum of its parts.  We lose all sense of time and place since we never see them eat or sleep or hell, wash up.  To the viewer it’s an endless journey while it isn’t until you watch the extras you realize it has been only three days. Director D.J. Caruso moves things along almost too quickly, not letting the relationships build while continuing to amp up the stakes.

LaBeouf is 21 and plays 25 pretty well, avoiding to come across as any of his previous characters.   He and Monaghan play off one another rather well but his Jerry rises to the occasion and becomes a hero like his deceased twin but the film ends before we find what he chooses to do with this newfound knowledge. Monaghan’s single mom is less developed and goes along for the ride in the name of her son.

The extras provide a glimpse at a nice alternate ending, a handful of deleted scenes, and some fun bloopers.  The various pieces on the making of the film feel perfunctory but provide some nice insight into the filmmaker’s goals.  There’s also a conversation between Caruso and Badham comparing their films and how much technology has changed over the last 20 years.